May 15, 2024

A Pastor’s Lament

How long, O Lord? Will you forget me forever?
How long will you hide your face from me?
How long must I bear pain in my soul,
and have sorrow in my heart all day long?
How long shall my enemy be exalted over me?

Those are the words of lament that have been on my heart and mind from Psalm 13 this past week as I have been grieving the senseless murder of nine brothers and sisters in Christ at Emmanuel AME church.  I have been weepy this past week when I think of this great tragedy.  How long, Lord?  How long?  How long?  Why?  Why?

We at Sycamore Creek Church may not be familiar with our connection to the AME church.  AME stands for African Methodist Episcopal.  While we don’t wear it on our sleeve, Sycamore Creek Church is a United Methodist Church.  Before the United Methodist Church was the UMC it was the Methodist Church.  Before it was the Methodist Church it was the Methodist Episcopal Church.  When it was the Methodist Episcopal Church some black brothers and sisters split off from the church in 1976 to begin their own church, the African Methodist Episcopal Church.  They split off because of the Methodist Episcopal Church’s segregation policies.

The AME is the oldest Independent denomination founded by African Americans.  It was founded by Richard Allen, a former slave whose slave holder after hearing a Methodist preacher preach against slavery was convicted to allow his slaves to buy their freedom.  Allen became a Methodist preacher but was only allowed to preach to other blacks.  Eventually the segregation led him to leave and start his own Methodist denomination.  The AME is not the only church to leave the Methodist church over race issues.  The AME Zion church and the CME (Colored/Christian Methodist Episcopal) are two other prominent examples.

You can see in the name African Methodist Episcopal the scar of the racism of our past.  While there has been some very significant healing and reconciliation over the years, it is not complete.  It is not complete in our church and it certainly not complete in our culture and nation as we saw this past week.

If you are like me you are asking, “What can I do?”  I want to suggest four things you can do.

First, when someone tells you they are planning to hurt someone, let the appropriate people know.  While I am bound by confidentiality as your pastor, there are two things that I will not and cannot hold in confidence.  The first is if you tell me you plan to hurt yourself.  If you tell me that I will not hold it in confidence.  I will do what I can do to keep you safe.  The second is if you tell me you are going to hurt someone else.  If you tell me that, I will do what I can to keep safe those you plant to hurt.  If I as your pastor cannot hold that confidence, then I want you to know that you should not hold it either.  If you know someone is going to hurt someone, then let the appropriate authorities know.

Second, commit to resolving conflicts peaceably.  As we talked about this past week in our current series, commit to fighting fair both with your spouse and with all those around you.  Practice gentle start-ups.  Learn how to complain without criticizing.  Accept influence from those around you.  Renegotiate your expectations peacefully when they are broken.  Violence is never the answer to resolve conflicts.

Third, build diverse friendships with people who are different than you.  This is a value I have personally and that our church shares as well.  When was that last time you had someone over for dinner who was different than you ethnically or socioeconomically?  When did you last eat a meal with someone who has a different sexual identity than you?  Or someone who has different political ideas than you do?  Friendship is a key to reconciliation.  When you build friendships with people who are different than you, you begin to be able to see the world through their eyes.

I have had to look in the mirror this week and realize and confess that I have very few friends if any in Lansing who are different than me ethnically.  My District Superintended suggested that we send notes to the pastor of the largest AME church in Lansing.  I did not know her name.  Why not?  Why has it taken a severe tragedy for me to know that Rev. Lila Martin is the pastor of Trinity AME in Lansing?  That’s part of the problem, isn’t it?

The fourth thing you can do is pray.  Pray for the people of Emanuel A.M.E. and for the families of loved ones who were lost or wounded.  Pray for the people of Charlestown, SC, and for our country.  Pray for racial reconciliation, forgiveness, and healing around the world.  Jesus stretches us to the breaking point when he commands us to pray for our enemies so pray for the perpetrator of this great crime.  And pray for an end to violence.  Lord have mercy.

Peace,
Pastor Tom

P.S. If you’d like to read some more thoughts on the issue of prejudice and racism, I offer this blog post I wrote a couple of years ago after the acquittal of George Zimmerman: Confessions of a White Pastor.

Confessions of a White Pastor

52-racismI wade into deep waters with this blog post.  On July 5th, my family welcomed Samuel Lewis into our family.  Over the next week we were in the bliss and busyness of adjusting everything about our family to welcoming Sam.  We’re still in that transitional time.  Over this same period, the family of our nation struggled with the acquittal of George Zimmerman in the shooting of Trayvon Martin.  I don’t intend to parse the evidence or trial in this post.  I barely paid attention to it given the new reality in our home, but given the reaction to the silence of the white church from some of my black friends, I wanted to share some reflections that might be helpful to us all when it comes to racism in our culture.

While I was an undergraduate at Wheaton College I took a course titled Advanced Developmental.  It focused on gender and race in psychological development.  We were assigned an article to read by Charles Ridley, a psychologist at Indiana University. This article made a distinction that changed the way I looked at racism in our culture and pointed my life in a different direction.  I believe this distinction can be helpful to us in light of the tragic shooting of Trayvon Martin and subsequent trial of George Zimmerman.

As I remember it, Ridley made the case that there is a clear distinction between prejudice and racism.  Prejudice is an attitude, whereas racism is a system, a system that tends to regularly benefit one race over another.  The distinction is important, because someone can participate in and contribute to a racist system and even benefit from it without necessarily having prejudicial attitudes.

What this distinction allowed me to do as a white man was to be open to the idea that my actions might perpetuate a system that provided privilege to one race over another, while not actively engaging in prejudicial attitudes toward other races.  This is not to say that I never have sinful prejudicial attitudes.  Rather, it is to say that this distinction allowed me to be open to my own culpability in perpetuating racist systems even if I didn’t want to be doing so.

The flip side of this distinction is that it motivated me to work toward becoming more aware of and breaking down racist systems.  I began to sense a call to racial (and economic) reconciliation.  My heart was open to my actions and decisions being searched and challenged by my friends and God.  I began to ask questions about how my decisions to live in certain neighborhoods and not other neighborhoods perpetuated racist systems that didn’t give the same privilege of choice to all people.  I began to ask questions about how my spending habits put money in the pockets of some people and not others.  I began to ask questions about how the friends I chose or tended to spend time developing kept me from seeing certain experiences of people who were different than my friends.  I began to ask these questions and be open to the uncomfortable truth that my decisions and actions just might perpetuate racist systems.

For those racists systems to be broken down, I had to change my decisions and actions.  So I chose to live in the ghetto while in seminary, a predominately minority neighborhood.  I saw how the actions of a few in that neighborhood terrorized the many and gave a bad reputation to the neighborhood as a whole.  I saw how the flight of resources from that neighborhood made it even more difficult to overcome the obstacles to wellbeing for all.

I chose to look at my investments and see whether the companies that were paying dividends into my retirement fund had a history of diversity in leadership and community impact or whether they had a history of homogeneity.  I decided to reinvest my retirement funds in a socially screened mutual fund.

I chose to begin to invest time in building friendships with people who were not white.  I spent intentional time talking about the issues of race with these new friends. I began to see that they saw things and experienced things that I was blind to seeing and experiencing.  Slowly I began to see some of the things they were seeing.

I don’t know whether Mr. Zimmerman acted out of prejudice in his choices, but I have no doubt that there are many racist systems in our culture that have contributed to this tragedy.  I’d encourage each of us to ask ourselves difficult questions about how we perpetuate those systems by our actions and decisions.  One of the best ways to do so is to cultivate friendships with people who are different than you: different racially, different politically, different socioeconomically, different in education, different in age, different in nationality, different in religion and faith.  My hope is that the church can be a catalyst for those kinds of friendships.  We have a long way to go to embody that reality, but with God’s help, we will accomplish that dream.

Here are a couple of resources that might be a good place to begin further reflection:

My friend Enuma’s article about the silence of her white church.

CNN article about the silence of white churches.

United Methodist Bishops’ reflections.

A Testament of Hope: The Essential Writings and Speeches of Martin Luther King, Jr.